Gathered Work

Colorado School of Mines.

Detection status
No AI-text detector is documented as deployed. Mines' own Faculty Guidance for Generative AI states "Mines discourages the use of AI detection tools for the purpose of detecting academic misconduct" and that such tools "cannot be used as the only evidence for determining responsibility for academic misconduct"; the same guidance directs faculty toward inviting the student into a conversation about their work instead.
Office in these sources
Office of Community Standards · Kim Lair, Assistant Director of Community Standards · kimberly.lair@mines.edu · no office-specific phone or address published
Ombuds or advocacy office
None located on the institution's own pages in this review.
Sources last checked
Oct 22, 2026
This record
Assembled from 4 linked documents on 2 hosts · change log below: 1 dated entry, Oct 22, 2026 · human review confirmed Oct 22, 2026 · the change record across every page · the collection in numbers

Reproduced from the institution's own pages quoted below — potentially relevant official sources, not a determination of which one governs any case.

Colorado School of Mines's published sources on AI detection and academic integrity, quoted and linked below. These are potentially relevant official sources, not a determination of which one governs any case — course syllabi and instructor expectations may also apply. Confirm applicability with the institution. Any dates are quoted from the sources, not a deadline calculation performed for you.

01Detection status

No detector deployed, and institutional guidance against one

A named-vendor sweep (Turnitin and its AI-writing indicator specifically, SimCheck, Originality, Copyleaks, iThenticate, GPTZero, Originality.ai, Winston AI, Crossplag, ZeroGPT, Packback, Grammarly Authorship, Honorlock, Proctorio, Respondus, Examity) against mines.edu found none of these named anywhere, including no page describing a Turnitin license or any similarity-checking tool. Mines' Faculty Guidance for Generative AI (retrieved Oct 22, 2026) addresses detection directly, in its FAQ "May I use AI tools to detect whether my students are using AI on an assignment?":

"Mines discourages the use of AI detection tools for the purpose of detecting academic misconduct. Research continues to confirm the unreliability and biases of such tools. Because they use AI to detect AI, detection tools can produce false positives, flagging human-written work as AI-generated or vice versa. This means that they cannot be used as the only evidence for determining responsibility for academic misconduct." "Moreover, instructors uploading student work to external tools may violate FERPA and Mines' IP policy, as these platforms lack the data protections of our officially contracted models."

Source: Faculty Guidance for Using Generative AI in Teaching at Mines. This is guidance discouraging adoption, not a statement that Mines ever licensed or deployed an AI-writing detector; no page located in this review confirms such deployment. DISQUALIFICATION CHECK: not disqualified — the finding is an absence of any documented detector, carried alongside institutional guidance recommending against adopting one, rather than a withdrawal of a tool already in use. The academic misconduct policy's own definitions of Dishonest Conduct, Plagiarism, Falsification/Fabrication, Tampering, Cheating, Impeding and Sharing Work name no AI-specific category or detection method.

PROCESS-BASED VERIFICATION FOUND, carried into the status line above: the same Faculty Guidance, at FAQ "What should I do if I suspect my student might have misused genAI in a way that violates academic integrity?", directs faculty toward a conversation rather than a detector score:

"Noticing these anomalies can serve as an indicator to pause and invite the student into a conversation about their work... This process includes a faculty-student meeting in which both the student and instructor can provide their perspective regarding the potential misconduct... one that begins with curiosity—inviting the student to explain their work and walk you through their process, methodology, or the context behind their work. If a student admits to using AI inappropriately or is entirely unable to explain the inconsistencies, core logic, or choices behind their own submission, this would provide sufficient evidence for reporting academic misconduct."

Source: Faculty Guidance for Using Generative AI in Teaching at Mines.

02Published process

What the academic misconduct policy's published guidance says

Who may be present
"Students and faculty are allowed to invite one support person each to the meeting. A support person must remain quiet during the meeting and may prepare with the student and faculty member in advance." At the appeal stage, "[b]oth student and faculty are allowed to bring a support person to join them on the call." Recording of either meeting is not addressed in the sources reviewed. — Student Guidance, Academic Integrity and Misconduct · Student Guidance
What follows on the record
A first offense carries "[n]otation of first offense in disciplinary record"; a second, "'F' in the course and inability to withdraw. Notation of second offense in disciplinary record." A third or greater offense carries "'F' in the course. Suspension from school for 1-year minimum (calendar year). 'Suspension as a result of Academic Misconduct' permanently noted on university transcript." — Student Guidance, Academic Integrity and Misconduct · Student Guidance

The two questions an adviser raises first, answered from this institution's own published documents — or recorded as not stated in them.

From the Student Guidance page (retrieved Oct 22, 2026): a faculty member who suspects misconduct must "notify and meet with the student(s) involved in an alleged academic misconduct policy within 10 business days," then report a determination of responsibility to the Office of Community Standards "within 5 business days" of the meeting. The Office of Community Standards then sends a resolution notice "within 5 business days of the case being reported." A student may appeal on three grounds, one of which ties directly to the evidentiary standard a faculty decision must meet:

"Unsupported Decision. To determine whether the decision reached by the faculty member was supported using the preponderance of evidence standard to establish that a violation of the policy occurred. This ground for appeal requires the student to show that no reasonable person could have determined that the student was responsible or could have imposed the sanctioned issued based on the available evidence."

The other two grounds are Due Process ("procedural errors must have been so substantial as to effectively deny the student a reasonable opportunity to prepare and present information") and New Information. Appeals are "managed through Dr. Derek Morgan, Dean of Students," and move to a Student Conduct Appeals Board "made up of 16 individuals who represent students, staff, and faculty," with "[a] minimum of three Board members (including 1 student and 1 faculty member)" required. The Board may reverse the faculty decision, affirm it, or forward the case to the Office of Academic Affairs for further consideration; a decision is "communicated to the student and faculty member within 24 hours of the conclusion of the appeal meeting," and the Board's decision (or the Office of Academic Affairs' decision on a forwarded case, due within 10 business days) "is final and shall be considered binding upon all involved, from which no additional appeals are permitted." Source: Student Guidance. What these quotations mean for any particular case is for the institution and its process to determine; they are reproduced so you can read the originals in context.

03Source map

Where the documents live

DocumentLocation
Academic Integrity (landing page)student-life.mines.edu/community-standards/academic-integrity
Student Guidance, Academic Integrity and Misconductstudent-life.mines.edu/.../student-guidance
Faculty Guidance for Using Generative AI in Teaching at Minesmines.edu/academic-affairs/faculty-ai-guidance
Office of Community Standards (team page; office contacts)student-life.mines.edu/community-standards — Kim Lair, kimberly.lair@mines.edu

Organizing your own drafts and records to bring to any of this: the records checklist. Capturing the pages above as they read today, and keeping your own dated record beside them: what to do with these sources.

04Change log

Revision history of this page

2026-10-22 — Page created. Priority A tranche 4, entry 290. Cold build (scheduled, unattended); no prior CANDIDATES.md/procedure-facts.json research to reuse. All quotations retrieved this date; none of the three captured pages displays its own revision date beyond the site-wide footer copyright. Named-vendor sweep (Turnitin and its AI-writing indicator specifically, SimCheck, Originality, Copyleaks, iThenticate, GPTZero, Originality.ai, Winston AI, Crossplag, ZeroGPT, Packback, Grammarly Authorship, Honorlock, Proctorio, Respondus, Examity) against mines.edu's own site search and a general web search restricted to the domain found none of these named anywhere on mines.edu. CATEGORY SWEEP: the Student Guidance and Faculty Guidance pages (Office of Community Standards) and the Faculty Guidance for Using Generative AI (Academic Affairs/Trefny Innovative Instruction Center) named no detection tool as deployed; the generative-AI guidance instead discourages adopting one. DISQUALIFICATION CHECK: not disqualified — absence of a documented detector, carried alongside guidance against adopting one, not a withdrawal. EVIDENTIARY WEIGHT, carried into the status line: "they cannot be used as the only evidence for determining responsibility for academic misconduct." PROCESS-BASED VERIFICATION FOUND, carried into the status line: the same Faculty Guidance directs an instructor who suspects misuse toward a faculty-student conversation "that begins with curiosity" about the student's process and reasoning, rather than toward a detector score. PROCESS, FROM THE STUDENT AND FACULTY GUIDANCE PAGES (Office of Community Standards, same content on both, confirmed by comparing the two pages' full text): the 10-business-day faculty notification-and-meeting window, the one-support-person accompaniment right at both the initial meeting and the appeal call, the tiered automatic sanctions (notation / F-and-no-withdrawal / F-plus-one-year-suspension-with-permanent-transcript-notation), the preponderance-of-evidence standard quoted from the "Unsupported Decision" appeal ground, and the Student Conduct Appeals Board's binding, non-appealable decision. SOURCE-MARKUP DEFECT FOUND: the Student and Faculty Guidance pages both link an "Email" button beneath Kim Lair's staff card to seralston@mines.edu (the Director of Community Standards, Samantha Ralston's address), not to Kim Lair's own address; Kim Lair's correct address, kimberly.lair@mines.edu, is instead given in the body text of both pages and on the Office of Community Standards' team page (confirmed by its own mailto links), and that correct address is what the docket uses. RECORDING: not addressed in either guidance page for the faculty meeting or the appeal call; the Student Code of Community Conduct and other university-wide conduct documents were not searched this pass since the misconduct policy's own guidance pages supply a complete process on their own terms. OFFICE: no office-specific phone number or street address is published on the Office of Community Standards' own pages, which list only the university's general line (303-273-3000) and named staff emails; the docket therefore gives Kim Lair's contact rather than a general office line. OMBUDS: a bounded sweep (mines.edu's own site search for "ombuds," returning zero results, plus an unrestricted web search for "mines.edu ombudsperson") found no dedicated office; none located. Nothing paraphrase-pending. Traces to tools/packets/mines-packet.txt with zero failures; gated in tools/fidelity-gate.txt. Archive captures pending — not requested this pass (unattended scheduled run). Reviewer: Carrie Schluter (review confirmed 2026-10-22).

Spot an error or an outdated quotation? hello@gatheredwork.com — corrections are made on the record, in this log.